Communion: sliding up and down on the pole of Metaphor
I was re-rereading ‘The Soul of Cyberspace’ by Jeff Zaleski (interesting book — you might enjoy it). He interviews John Perry Barlow the co-founder of the Electronic Frontiers Foundation. Jeff makes the following statement about sacraments on the net which ignites a conversation about metaphors.
JZ: The Catholic Church has many websites, but they haven’t yet put any sacraments onto the net.
JPB: I wonder why that is?
JZ: Probably because a lot of religions believe that sacramental energy has an intimate and necessary connection with the body.
JPB: Ah. That’s what it is. Let’s take Communion. What communion is really about is the experience of entering that metaphorical gap between the wine and the blood. If you don’t have the grounding in the wine, the physical manifestation, I can see where they would think that there’s no potential for that holy voltage between the physical symbol and the spiritual reality.
JZ: What do you think?
JPB: I think there probably right in a way. One of the reasons people have such a difficult time understanding metaphor now is because most people actually live in a metaphorical condition all the time.You know, they’re living in this completely informational environment where there’s no relationship to the physical world anyway, so what the hell would a metaphor be? Metaphors always have that grounding element. And so much of what the spiritual process is about is sliding up and down between those poles of the physical and the immaterial.
I’m finishing up a paper on ‘Internet Communion’ for a Liturgical Theology class and am fascinated with some of the ongoing scholarship related to religion online. Is the internet the air we breath — and in 100 years religious communities will worship, receive the sacraments online and never have been physically in the same room? Or is it a corruption of the very fabric of our lives together — a symptom of the pervasive individualism and fragmentation of our social diseases - and no good will ever come from the mixture of religion and the net?
Thoughts?
Addition after the fact… More of my thoughts on this subject can be found on these other posts: Communion on the Internet, and Religion, Faith, and Online Gaming
